.svg)
.webp)
On paper, short term rental investing can look like a dream. Spreadsheets highlight high nightly rates, rising demand, and a strong return on investment. But the reality is more complicated. Behind the glossy numbers are hidden costs, shifting regulations, and platform fees that steadily eat away at margins. What seems profitable at first glance often feels much tighter once you’re in the middle of managing guests, compliance, and operations.
Below, we’ll walk through the costs that don’t always make it into a pro forma and give you a checklist of what to model before you commit to buying. That way, your numbers reflect the business you’ll actually be running, not just the one your spreadsheet promised.
1. Compliance, Permits, and Penalties
Before you even welcome your first guest, you need to think about compliance. Most cities now require short term rental licenses, which means application fees, annual renewals, and sometimes even inspections. For example, Denver has a clear licensing program with specific rules and active enforcement, so skipping the paperwork is not an option.
The challenge is that rules don’t always stay the same. Local governments can introduce new ordinances that limit the number of nights you can host or add unexpected fees. If you’re caught out of compliance, fines and even suspensions are very real risks.
On top of that, there are hotel and occupancy taxes to register and report. Platforms like Airbnb or Vrbo may collect some of these taxes on your behalf, but ultimately the responsibility still falls on you. Keeping up with reporting requirements can be an ongoing headache if you are not prepared.
2. Platform Fees and Payout Frictions
One of the first surprises new hosts run into is how much of their payout never makes it into their bank account. On Airbnb, most hosts are charged around a 3 percent service fee under the split-fee model, while some pay more depending on their setup. If you use property management software, Airbnb often moves you into a host-only fee structure, which means you shoulder the full cut.
Vrbo has its own model. If you choose pay-per-booking, expect a commission of about 5 percent plus another 3 percent for payment processing. That is a solid chunk off the top before you see your share.
Cancellations and chargebacks are another headache. A host-initiated cancellation can trigger penalties, while guest disputes or chargebacks take time and energy to resolve. On top of that, Vrbo requires certain guest-facing fees to be displayed as “partner-collected fees,” which adds extra admin work to keep everything transparent.
3. Taxes You Didn’t Model (or Mis-Modeled)
Taxes are one of the easiest things to overlook when running the numbers for a short term rental. Occupancy or lodging taxes, for example, might be collected by Airbnb in some cities but left entirely to the host in others. If you assume the platform always handles it, you could end up with a surprise bill or even penalties down the road.
Then there’s sales tax, VAT, or GST depending on where your property is located. These aren’t optional, and hosts are responsible for knowing what applies in their market. Missing this piece can throw off your cash flow quickly.
Finally, don’t forget about account holds or withholding. If your tax information isn’t up to date, platforms can delay payouts or set aside a portion of your earnings until you get compliant. All of these details add up and should be built into your model from the start.
4. Insurance Gaps and Risk Transfer Costs
Most standard homeowner’s policies simply do not cover short term rental activity. If you plan to host guests regularly, you’ll need a dedicated STR or “commercial homeowners” policy, or at the very least a special endorsement. Companies like Obie specialize in this type of coverage, and sources such as Investopedia also highlight the importance of securing the right protection before listing your property.
Be prepared for higher premiums and unique deductibles too. Wind and hail coverage, named storm deductibles, and liability limits are often structured differently than what you’re used to with a traditional homeowner’s policy.
It’s also worth pointing out that Airbnb’s AirCover should not be viewed as a replacement for true insurance. It can help in certain cases, but it is limited in scope. Think of it as a safety net, not a substitute for comprehensive protection.
5. Operations: Cleaning, Laundry, and Restocking Creep
One of the first surprises for new short term rental hosts is just how quickly cleaning costs add up. Every turnover means hiring cleaners, and pricing can swing a lot depending on property size and location. Many cleaners also handle laundry and light staging, which is convenient but not cheap. Tools like Futurestay can help streamline scheduling, but the bills still come due.
Then there’s linen and laundry. Towels, sheets, and pillowcases wear out much faster with constant guest use. Between the utilities, detergent, and vendor fees, it becomes a recurring line item that grows faster than most people expect. Services such as Turno can automate cleaner assignments, but the underlying costs remain.
Finally, the little things pile up. Toilet paper, soap, coffee, filters, and lightbulbs all need restocking. None of these are huge on their own, but together they become the classic death by a thousand cuts that quietly eats into your margins.
6. Utilities and Guest Behavior Load
Many new hosts underestimate how much utility costs jump with short term rentals. Since you cover the bills, guests tend to run the air conditioning colder in the summer, crank the heat higher in the winter, and leave lights on all day. Laundry adds up too, with smaller and more frequent loads after every stay.
Hosts on BiggerPockets and other forums often point out that their electric and water bills are noticeably higher than they were with long term tenants. On top of the bills themselves, this heavier use puts extra wear on appliances like washers, dryers, and dishwashers, which means repairs and replacements come sooner than expected. The takeaway is simple: budget more for utilities and appliance upkeep than your spreadsheet might suggest.
7. Tech Stack & Subscriptions Most Newbies Skip
When most people run the numbers on a short term rental, they focus on mortgage payments, cleaning, and utilities. What often gets overlooked are the tools and subscriptions that make hosting actually manageable.
Dynamic pricing software like PriceLabs, Wheelhouse, or Beyond can give you a revenue boost by adjusting rates in real time, but each one charges a monthly fee per listing. Over the course of a year, those fees add up quickly.
Then there’s monitoring. Devices like Minut and NoiseAware help track noise levels and occupancy to prevent parties, neighbor complaints, or costly fines. They usually require both an upfront hardware purchase and an ongoing subscription.
On top of that, many hosts end up paying for property management systems, smart lock platforms, and data analytics tools. None of these costs are huge on their own, but together they become a steady monthly bill that eats into your profit.
8. Turnover-Driven Maintenance and Capex
Guests are tougher on linens, towels, cookware, and even patio furniture than long term tenants. That means you will be replacing these items much sooner than you probably expect. Small appliances like toasters or coffee makers often have a shorter life too.
Beyond the basics, frequent minor repairs come with the territory. Scuffed walls, loose cabinet handles, or clogged drains often need attention between stays. You will also need to budget for deep cleans and periodic carpet or sofa steaming to keep the property fresh and guest-ready.
Finally, don’t forget the marketing side. To maintain strong booking conversion, staging and updated photography are a periodic reinvestment. Fresh images and a polished look can pay for themselves, but they are another cost that rarely shows up in the first spreadsheet.
9. Financing & Cash-Flow Friction
Most investors run their numbers with a clean monthly mortgage line, but real-world financing costs are rarely that neat. Lenders may tack on points, require rate buydowns, or charge a premium for DSCR loans. You might also face reserve requirements that tie up capital longer than expected, and down the road a refinance can bring fresh closing costs you did not plan for.
Even after you close, the cash flow itself is not as smooth as your spreadsheet suggests. Platforms sometimes hold deposits, payouts can lag, and slower seasons create gaps in income. Without a cushion, these hiccups can leave you scrambling. A smart move is to build in a working-capital buffer so you can handle a few months of fixed costs without stress.
10. Security, Fraud, and Disputes
Every short term rental host eventually faces the less glamorous side of the business: security issues and payment disputes. Guests can file chargebacks with their credit card companies, which means you may spend time gathering receipts, correspondence, and proof of stay just to defend money you thought was already yours. Even if you win, the process can drag on and tie up your cash flow.
Another point to keep in mind is that platforms like Airbnb do not allow you to collect extra fees off the platform. Trying to skirt those rules can put your listing at risk, so it is safer to work within their system.
Finally, while Airbnb offers a Resolution Center for damage claims, reimbursement is not automatic. You’ll need to document everything, submit the claim, and wait for a decision. Sometimes you get paid, sometimes you don’t, so it is wise to budget for losses.
11. Neighborhood & Compliance Risk Mitigations
One of the easiest ways to sink your short term rental business is by ignoring the neighborhood around it. Guests may not mean to cause problems, but late-night gatherings or too many people coming and going can quickly turn into complaints. Once the neighbors get frustrated, it can lead to police calls or city fines that cost far more than prevention.
That is where noise monitoring devices come in. They track volume levels without recording conversations, giving you an early warning if a party is brewing. The monthly fee might feel like another line item, but it is usually far cheaper than one serious violation.
Beyond that, keep in mind that local rules are never set in stone. Cities often revise ordinances, add new permit requirements, or expand hotel taxes to cover STRs. Building in a buffer for these changes will help you stay compliant and avoid nasty surprises.
12. Accounting, Admin, and Your Time (Opportunity Cost)
Another overlooked cost in short term rental investing is the time and energy it takes to keep the books clean. If you’re hosting in multiple cities or states, you’ll likely face different tax rules and reporting requirements. That means you need a reliable system for tracking what the platforms collect on your behalf and what you’re still responsible for remitting. Without a clear audit trail, tax season can become a headache.
Then there’s the day-to-day admin that rarely shows up in a spreadsheet. Guest messaging, handling issues, and coordinating with cleaners all take time. Even with automation tools, someone has to step in when a problem comes up. Whether it’s you or a manager you pay, that time has a cost attached. Ignoring it makes the numbers on your pro forma look a lot better than the reality of running the business.
What to Add to Your Model (Practical Checklist)
If you want your numbers to hold up in the real world, you need to budget for more than just mortgage, cleaning, and management. A strong model should include line items that reflect the true cost of operating a short term rental. Think of it as building a buffer between you and unpleasant surprises.
Start with the basics like permits and licensing, plus platform fees for each channel you plan to use. Factor in the higher cost of STR-specific insurance compared to a standard homeowner’s policy. Don’t forget utilities, which fluctuate with the seasons, and cleaning or linen turnover costs along with regular restocking. Add your tech stack, including pricing tools, PMS subscriptions, and noise monitoring services.
Finally, set aside reserves: 8–12% of revenue for maintenance, a capex fund for furniture and equipment, money for bookkeeping or CPA support, and a contingency bucket for regulatory changes or disputes. Top it off with a working-capital cushion that covers two to three months of fixed costs. That’s what keeps your operation running smoothly when the unexpected happens.
Conclusion: Profit on Paper vs. Profit in Practice
It’s easy to get excited when the spreadsheet shows big profits, but short term rentals live and die on real-world details. Treating an STR like an operating business instead of just a property is the only way to know if the numbers will truly hold. Once you load in the hidden costs, you can see whether your investment has the strength to weather cleaning cycles, regulations, and surprise expenses. If the deal still makes sense after that, you know you’ve found something solid.
If you want support running the day-to-day without losing sight of the bigger picture, Awning’s property management services can help. We handle the operations, compliance, and guest experience so your revenue isn’t just a line on a spreadsheet, it’s money in your pocket.
%201.png)
%203.png)
%201.png)
.png)
